Skip to main content

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING?

Incident Prevention Magazine - Utility Safety

When Safety Takes the Back Seat

Written by Chris Beach, CUSP on . Posted in .

“Do you think we have enough cover on this?”

Nearly every lineworker has asked or heard the question. And you may be familiar with these responses: “Yeah, you’re nowhere near anything.” “Just don’t reach out that far and you’ll be fine.” “The sooner you get to work, the sooner we go home.”

In effect, the lineworker’s question gets waved off or dismissed, and the hazard shrinks in the telling.

None of us are immune to this. Early in my time leading crews, I made a call that resulted in serious injury to a coworker. We were rebuilding a cellular site on a concrete monopole set in the middle of a 138-kV transmission line. The line was de-energized and grounded for the work, but the outage window came in shorter than planned. We combined two crews to beat the clock, which was normal for bigger jobs. What wasn’t normal was my idea to run both aerial lifts at once on different parts of the job.

I warned crew members about dropped objects yet neglected to remind them to check the location of the other bucket before breaking anything loose. I didn’t call for constant communication between the lifts, nor did I assign a spotter to focus solely on bucket positioning, ensuring that one bucket never operated above the other. I assumed everyone on the crew was adequately trained in material securement and understood the potential consequences of a pipe falling from height.

But after work began, a pipe was loosened, fell and shattered the forearm of a worker below. Had it fallen just a bit differently, the pipe could have hit the worker’s head or neck and killed him.

My point here is that although our crew put controls in place to address the jobsite’s 138-kV hazard, we never gave the pipe a second thought. As crew leader, I was aiming for efficiency. The reality is that I minimized what could go wrong – and another worker paid the price.

Error Margins and Complacency
Drive a vehicle long enough and eventually you learn that speeding doesn’t necessarily cause crashes. It does, however, reduce your error margin should the unexpected occur. Jobs in our industry work much the same way. For instance, a condensed schedule may not directly cause a pipe to fall and injure a worker, but it could cut spotters, limit helpful discussions and reduce situational awareness.

That’s how complacency works its way into our trade. We downplay hazards to keep the work moving; most days, nothing bad happens. American sociologist Diane Vaughan first referred to this phenomenon as “normalization of deviance” in her 1996 book, “The Challenger Launch Decision.” Essentially, each “successful” shortcut that a worker takes becomes proof that the shortcut is a safe work method. Apprentices who are watching may learn that as the standard method, unaware of the best practice.

Management can unintentionally feed into this. As a crew leader, I avoided difficult conversations about shortcuts because I wanted people to like me. I didn’t realize at the time that each conversation I skipped silently communicated to the crew that their behavior was acceptable. Today, I call out shortcuts when I see them, then share stories about my own near misses and leadership mistakes. It is tough for trainers to effect change in others if they are not willing to speak candidly about their own errors.

Space to Fail
Tight production schedules can also eliminate or vastly reduce opportunities for seasoned professionals to share their knowledge with greener crew members. After moving from crew leadership into safety and training, this was something that I wanted to change.

What I didn’t realize at the time was just how many unhealthy behaviors I had brought with me from my previous role. Due to a fear of failure brought about by the pipe incident, I attempted to train failure out of people entirely. An apprentice called me out one day as we practiced clipping in bundled transmission conductors on a tower. I was standing behind him, talking through every step, telling him how I would do it. He turned around and told me to let him fail.

The apprentice’s response was spot-on. I hadn’t given him time or space to try, make a mistake and learn while stakes were low. Instead, I’d merely repeated what I’d been taught, which clearly wasn’t effective. After 13 years in the trade, that moment hit me hardest.

The Beauty of Training Yard Mistakes
Here’s the thing: failure is inevitable. Given that reality, we must offer employees training opportunities that allow them to fail safely, and we must plan jobs with enough error margin to safeguard workers when someone gets it wrong. Our job isn’t to eliminate every mistake but to ensure that no mistake is fatal.

After my interaction with the apprentice at the tower, leadership decided to carve out space to fail in our training yard, which enabled apprentices and journeymen to practice various jobs in controlled conditions. Performance measures developed for each task were checked, step by step, as work was completed, creating conditions for specific feedback.

Naturally, mistakes happened in the training yard – that was the point. For example, one day an apprentice removed the ground end of a temporary protective ground before removing the conductor end. Doing so could have been fatal on an active jobsite, but in the training yard, the apprentice’s misstep provided an opportunity to stop work and offer a teaching moment to those watching.

A Brutal Year
2026 has been brutal to some of our newest brothers and sisters in the industry. A 21-year-old apprentice died this spring from injuries sustained during a bucket truck arc flash. The next month, a 20-year-old apprentice was killed on the job.

Production will undoubtedly continue to be a business priority, but we cannot continue to prioritize it at the expense of human health and safety. I fear that I will lose someone close to me should our industry continue down this path. If you’re reading this, I suspect you have had the same fear. That feeling shouldn’t sit well with any of us.

But what if we decided to actively use our fear and discomfort as motivation to (1) speak up about shortcuts every time we see them and (2) provide our crews with more opportunities to learn and fail safely? I am wholeheartedly committed to doing so. Will you join me?

About the Author: After a nearly 20-year career with CenterPoint Energy, Chris Beach, CUSP, currently serves as technical safety advisor for Principle Services LLC. Reach him at cbeach@principlesvc.com.